I'm tired of hearing people groan when a teacher says, “Okay! We’re going to go around the circle and everyone’s going to answer a little question I have for you.” They act as if telling their classmates their favorite ice cream flavor would be so unbearably painful that they would rather keel over than utter the words “mint chocolate chip.” Even worse than the classroom groaners are those who claim that there is no place for such trivial questions in their close relationships with their friends – as if someone’s preference over cats or dogs doesn’t tell you enough about them.
Don’t get me wrong, though. There is a time and place. I, too, have rolled my eyes at ice-breakers that were poorly timed and awkwardly delivered. But when we do encounter the right time and place, I think we need to learn to better appreciate these questions.
If you’re an ice-breaker denier, I don’t believe the problem is that deep down you just hate being asked questions about yourself. I also don’t think the problem is that you just can’t bear to ask another person such superfluous, surface-level questions. Instead, I propose the issue is just that you’ve never been asked the right one. My personal break-through moment occurred where all best schema-shifting moments do: a college tour. Before we started our campus stroll, the guide made our group go around in a circle and share which kitchen utensils we would be and why. (Note: I do not subscribe to the “why” inquiry of ice-breaker answers. If your gut tells you that you are a rubber spatula, then you are a rubber spatula. No explanation of functionality or appearance is necessary. This rule applies to all ice-breaker questions.) I wasn’t immediately convinced. Initially, I was distracted by the panic of not knowing my answer until he finally declared in which direction we would go around the circle. Then, I was completely focused on listening to my potential peers share their answers, in hopes of hearing anything that would spark inspiration for own. After fork and knife were offered up with mildly concerning rationale, I was at a loss. My turn was next, and I went for it: spoon. I would be a spoon. Why? I couldn’t tell them. So our guide, in earnest tour guide fashion, threw some ideas out there for me: “Oh, well, like, the round-ness is nice. Like, they are just kind-of pleasing to the eye, you know? And they’re pretty functional, like, you can actually do a lot more with a spoon than you’d think.” I politely agreed, acting as though he had taken the unrealized words from my mouth. Can a girl not be a spoon just because? Despite these minor set-backs, my moment of realizing my love for ice-breakers was mere minutes away. Once the rest of the group had shared some better answers – one or two of them even making me smile – I finally had THE thought: “Wow, that’s a really great ice-breaker question. These silly questions really can tell you a lot about a person.” You wouldn’t look at me the same if you knew how many people I’ve asked to share with me which kitchen utensil they would be.
Although I said that my Ice-Breaker Moment™ when I finally started to love ice-breakers came during that college tour, the truth is that such a conversion was never really necessary for me. I was a shy kid, but I still longed to feel known (and for attention). These questions opened up a space for me to speak and to let people get to know me like the way I wished they would. It just felt good to share a little something about myself to a group that was eagerly waiting to hear exactly which Disney princess I liked the most. Oh, the anticipation of waiting for my turn as each person in the circle shared, praying that no one would threaten my individuality complex by stealing my perfectly unique answer. (Note: No one did. I was the only one who claimed Mulan as my preferred princess.)
Some call it “asking half-strangers ice-breaker questions,” others (me) call it “the art of discovering deeper understanding through silly, superficial questions,” or something like that.
As a parting gift, I leave you with my personal favorite ice-breaker question: what’s your favorite? No typo there. Out of all your favorites, what's your favorite?
Mine? Fireworks.










